Here in the state of Georgia, there are a lot of schools in this area with the "zero-tolerance" stance on discipline in our schools and the idea that this is the best approach to keep students in line. However, these strict punishments that students receive when they break a rule can be very unnecessary at times, for example: http://www.myfoxatlanta.com/story/23561550/ga-lawmakers-seek-to-revisit-school-weapon-policy
The middle and high school I attended had "zero-tolerance" policies and for the most part, they helped students think twice before they got into trouble. However, for a student to get suspended and receive failing grades on assignments he misses while on suspension is ridiculous. These policies do need revision and I am very glad to see that this has grabbed the attention of policy-makers.
I am so glad that you brought this up in your blog. The policy is being taken out of context, and I am also glad that the story gained the attention of lawmakers. I remember a story published a few years ago where a little boy was expelled for bringing a key chain in the shape of a gun to his school. The zero tolerance policy, of course, allowed the school to take such drastic measures. I think that unless the person is presenting a problem, or making threats, then they should not be going through their vehicles in the first place. You do have a right to your privacy, and I also agree with you that they should make decisions about punishments and such based on records. Those teenagers are going to suffer not only during this school year, but if they decide to go to college that will reflect on their school records. They could have a tarnished name, all because they went fishing and forgot to remove their things from their vehicle.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree...Great Post!
DeleteMy first question is how and why are school officials checking the student's cars in the first place. After the teen that wore the NRA shirt to school was suspended and subject to jail time and a fine this year, it is clear zero tolerance policies need some work. Zero tolerance policies are overall extremely broad in hopes to cover everything which is dangerous. Over the last 5 years, elementary schools, middle schools, high schools and even colleges have experienced a spike in shootings. Rushed legislation and law making leads to shoddy policies like this.
ReplyDeleteI will say, however, that I do feel that is necessary to keep a weapon free school zone. You never know what pressures a student or faculty member could be under. Knowing they have weapons in the car could end badly. Zero tolerance policies aim to be preventative, but they are also problematic.
I definitely see your point, I believe the school officials are saying if it's "on campus" it's free game. The same as if it were within the school. With students being minors and usually attending a zero tolerance "public school", they have not yet been granted the same rights as adult citizens. Great post!
Delete